Monday 31 July 2023

Chōji-dachi, Fudō-dachi, and Naihanchi-dachi: Ideal Postures for all Directions



Two photos from Gigō Funakoshi’s “Ten-no-Kata” showing fudō-dachi

There are many different stances and postures in karate. Often in old karate, some version of T-stance (chōji-dachi) was used. Obviously that means it has genuine benefits for actual fighting, as opposed to always standing in some form of front stance when fighting, ready to move forwards or back, left or right, up or down. You can shift between zenkutsu-dachi, kokutsu-dachi, and naihanchi-dachi seemlessly with minimal movement, simply turning on the heels, in the old way that Gichin Funakoshi practised. Particularly from an open chōji-dachi, you can easily defend in multiple directions. However, you can use your hips better in a regular front stance, when attacking with the rear fist aiming forwards. But what about to the open side, for instance? Therefore, an angled naihanchi-dachi  is better for mutiple directions with minimal movement. This is like fudō-dachi, but high, so, because a low stance is useful at times, shifting between naihanchi-dachi and fudō-dachi is certainly advantageous, although always only in accordance. In actual fighting, it’s ideal to use minimal movement to change direction, apply maximum power using the body’s mechanics, shift your weight as necessary between yin and yang, be heavy, light, or strategically one then the other, depending, and move dynamically very actively when necessary, suddenly shifting the entire body swiftly, and always not allowing your opponent/s to so much as touch you with their attacks. All of the classical stances are useful, including the version of chōji-dachi in which the heels are in line. However, as with Gichin Funakoshi, you shouldn’t stick to one stance or kind of stance. Moving in accordance, every posture is valuable. But I feel that the different types of chōji-dachi, fudō-dachi, and naihanchi-dachi (the “horse” stance) are particularly applicable.

The various postures from Funakoshi karate that are, or relate to, chōji-dachi, by students at Tōkyō University

Kanei Uechi chōji-dachi

Isao Obata with a bō – a Funakoshi karate front-stance is sometimes actually chōji-dachi

Gichin Funakoshi using chōji-dachi, with the same technique as a student at Tōkyō University above


Gichin Funakoshi’s front and back stances, from “Karate Jutsu” (“Rentan Goshin Karate Jutsu”), 1925

From Shigeru Egami’s 1970 “Karate-Dō: For the Specialist”

Gichin Funakoshi using a natural-style posture that is like a relaxed chōji-dachi 

Kenneth Yoshinobu Funakoshi fudō-dachi from the kata sōchin

Gigō Funakoshi fudō-dachi – it looks like a front stance, but it’s noted that it is the immovable stance

Keiō karate sōchin including one version of fudō-dachi

Kenneth Funakoshi sōchin including the other version of fudō-dachi (otherwise called sōchin-dachi)


No comments:

Post a Comment